Censoring Huckleberry Finn

Mark Twain’s Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is a classic novel that has been on required reading lists at schools for many years since it was published in the U.S. in 1885, but in the past decades it has been relegated to optional reading or banned altogether. The reason? Huckleberry Finn repeats an offensive word: Nigger.

Okay, so the ‘N’ word is offensive, but at one unfortunate time in history, it was a common word. Now, Twain scholar, Alan Gribben and NewSouth Books, have decided to release a censored version of Huckleberry Finn and erase the ‘N’ word as well as ‘Injun’ and replace them with ‘slave’ in the hopes of saving the classic from being shoved aside and forgotten.

How noble of Mr. Gribben.

Somehow I think if Mark Twain were alive, he would object to this censorship as would most writers. And as a writer myself, I am bothered by the thought that characters that I created could be torn apart by some guy with noble ideas about making a book politically correct. I’m bothered by a story and characters being massacred by an editing pencil, changing the meaning of the story and ruining the character development by forcing the character to say something other than what he/she would have said in that time period of American history.

Also, by censoring this classic novel, Mr. Gribben is changing history, trying to sugar coat something that, though terrible, is a part of history. And there are others that oppose this censorship. And rightly so. After massacring Huck Finn, what’s next on the list?

“The use of the ‘N’ word,” notes Jesse Sheidlower of the Oxford English Dictionary, “is one way Twain condemns the prejudicial attitudes of the South.”

Isn’t learning about slavery and discussing what happened more important than trying to change history? Is ‘slave’ even a better choice? It has a completely different meaning than ‘Injun.’ Wouldn’t it be better to have discussions on how certain people used to be treated and how we don’t want to ever go back to that? Erasing an offensive word does not erase history and how people talked about other people.

Because a couple of offensive words might make some people uncomfortable, a classic novel is being ruined. Life is not all about nice words and smiling faces. Life is all about being uncomfortable. Get used to it.

 

Kelley Heckart

‘Timeless tales of romance, conflict & magic’

http://www.kelleyheckart.com

http://kelleysrealm.blogspot.com/ Check out my long hair hotties!

http://twitter.com/CelticChick

http://www.facebook.com/pages/Kelley-Heckart/111838455604

3 thoughts on “Censoring Huckleberry Finn”

  1. I am OVER political correctness for the sake of political correctness. Censorship of novels must absolutely STOP. Leave the words in there, it is a reminder of how much we have grown as human beings that we will no longer tolerate that language, that attitude, that negativity.

    I remember every single hateful thing I’ve done in my life and although I am not that person now, my recall reminds me where I’ve come from, where I going and what behavior I will no longer tolerate in myself. Leave the words, we have replaced them with better ones…tolerance, acceptance, respect, dignity…the old words only remind us of where we’re at, and although we have a ways to go, our learning curve is getting shorter and flatter by the day.

    Erin

    Like

  2. Kathleen and Erin, Thank you for your comments.
    Exactly–censoring the book will not remove what happened. It’s better to have discussions about old attitudes and slavery in the South so that we never go down that road again.

    Like

Please Share or by all means, COMMENT

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s